Heartless or Justified? Wife Refuses to House Mother-in-Law Because of Rottweiler

On the Internet, an individual shared his dilemma regarding his mother, who needs a place to stay. For the sake of his story, we’ll call him Gray. The issue here is that Gray’s wife adamantly refuses to let her live with them, as it would entail having to look after another guest: the mother’s giant pet Rottweiler.

Context: How Did The Mother Lose Her Home?

Woman Looking Shocked and Surprised MSN
Image Credit: Depositphotos

In the post, Gray started off with some context: his 59-year-old mother has a month to secure a new living situation. Her government-funded home was taken away by the state without prior notice. She’s currently unemployed because of her disability (she has Lupus, a disease that causes bodily inflammation.)

Gray’s Current Situation

Father and Daughter Smiling for Photograph Family Dad Kid Child MSN
Image Credit: AllaSerebrina on Depositphotos

Gray currently lives in a five-bedroom house with his wife and three children. Concerned about his mother, he considered letting her sleep in their shared office and moving the workspace to the attic. When Gray brought this up to his wife, the suggestion was immediately met with a stern “no.”

Why Won’t His Wife Allow The Mother to Live With Them?

Woman Looking Shocked Stressed and Saying No MSN
Image Credit: Depositphotos

Gray mentioned that his wife has a good relationship with his mother, even adding that his mom is probably more fond of her than she is of him.

However, housing Gray’s mother would mean dealing with her pet Rottweiler too. This condition aggravated his wife and started a heated argument between them. Gray tried to negotiate with her, but she responded by saying, “she won’t get rid of her dog, therefore she has no place here.”

Gray’s Aware Of The Dog Issue And Still Finds His Wife’s Reaction Absurd

Couple Man Woman Yelling and Shocked Surprised and Expressive MSN
Image Credit: Depositphotos

Gray was aware that she is not a fan of dogs, and that she was especially anxious around his mother’s Rottweiler because she was chased by one when she was young.

Yet, he found it absurd that his wife would choose to turn his mother away just because of her pet.

He Called Her Response “Over-The-Top”

angry woman holding shoes MSN
Image Credit: DepositPhotos

The wife stood firm in her stance—she wasn’t willing to dedicate time and energy towards caring for her disabled mother-in-law and a large, untrained dog on top of that.

He expressed that he thought her response was “over-the-top” and wrote that she was acting “rather ignorantly” for refusing to help.

The Dog Debate: Would It Be Dangerous To Keep a Rottweiler?

Bearded Man Shrugging Shoulders MSN
Image Credit: HBRH/DepositPhotos

The mere thought of living with a Rottweiler triggered the wife’s lifelong phobia. She feared that the dog would pose a threat to their kids, and said she was “absolutely repulsed” by Gray’s idea. She argued that letting the Rottweiler in their home would expose their kids to a hostile animal.

The Situation Caused a Major Rift in Their Relationship

Woman Showing Loser Sign MSN Angry Expressive
Image Credit: SIphotography/DepositPhotos

The situation has both Gray and his wife stressed out beyond belief. According to him, the issue had caused a major rift in their relationship. It reached a point where the wife implied that if Gray were to decide to prioritize his mother over their family’s well-being, he was free to leave for good.

In terms of legal ownership of the house, the wife has the upper hand, as she inherited it long before she met Gray.

Is The Wife’s Reaction Heartless or Justified?

Woman Shrugging Her Shoulders MSN
Image Credit: pressmaster/DepositPhotos

People who read Gray’s post left a number of comments sharing their opinions.

Many thought he was being insensitive for failing to consider his wife’s perspective. In their point of view, housing both the mother and the dog would inevitably pile extra responsibilities onto the wife, who already had an exhausting routine to begin with.

After all, she has a full-time job and three kids to manage, and constantly has to balance these duties with the unpaid labor of doing house chores.

Did Gray Really Look At It From His Wife’s Point of View?

Young Man Being Blinded And Covering Eyes MSN Shocked Surprised
Image Credit: NewAfrica/DepositPhotos

Commenters called Gray “insane” for expecting his wife to comply with his suggestion. Several users stated that he overlooked her traumatic experience with Rottweilers in the past, which influenced her reaction to having a dog of the same breed close by.

Taking Into Account Caring For A Disabled Parent

Caretaker Nurse Using Hot Water Bag On Senior Woman MSN
Image Credit: SimpleFoto/DepositPhotos

One user advised Gray not to underestimate the effort that would go into accommodating his disabled mother.

With all the doctor’s appointments, medications, increased expenses, and personal nursing care he would have to provide, it’s best that he look into other housing options for his mother, at least for now.

The Dark Side of Aging: 10 Things That Will Drive You Crazy as You Grow Older

Man Getting Angry and Pointing and Screaming MSN
Image Credit: Depositphotos

I recently saw this question online, “What are you starting to dislike more as you get older?” Here are the top-voted responses.

The Top 10 Saddest Songs of All Time – Be Prepared for #1 To Hit You Hard

Woman Sad and Crying and Depressed and Emotional MSN
Image Credit: HayDmitriy on Depositphotos

I was searching the internet for great music to listen to when I came across an interesting thread titled, “What is the saddest song you’ve ever heard?” Here are some of the responses with the most upvotes.

I Can’t Believe I Didn’t Know This Until Now: Embarrassing Things People Learned Way Too Late In Life

Serious Woman Crossing Her Arms No
Image credit: DepositPhotos

I recently scrolled the internet’s front page when I saw this question, “What’s something you learned “embarrassingly late” in life?” Here are the top-voted responses.

14 All-Time Favorite Celebrities Exposed as Secret Jerks-Prepare to Be Surprised

Oprah Winfrey MSN

I recently discovered an online discussion listing beloved celebrities who were revealed to have undesirable behind-the-scenes personas. As I read about the hidden sides of these public figures, my perceptions of them were flipped completely.

I Tried Living the European Way: 10 Luxuries That Left Me Wondering, ‘Why Don’t Americans Have This?’

Woman Smiling Happy Holding American Flag MSN

The internet sure is a pool of information. I was scrolling the front page of the internet when I saw this question, “Americans, what do Europeans have every day that you see as a luxury?” the top-voted responses are quite interesting, so I had to share these with you.

Because what do they have every day that Americans don’t?

Did You Fall for These 10 Commonly Believed Myths? Science Sets the Record Straight

Man Looking Shocked and Surprised, Unbelievable MSN
Image Credit: Depositphotos

I recently saw this question online, “What is a popular belief that is scientifically proven wrong?” 

Are you thinking of something you know now? Here are the responses that received the most upvotes.

Parenting Confessions: 10 Parents Admit What They Hate Most About Having a Child

Family Holding Hands MSN
Image Credit: Depositphotos

I recently scrolled the internet’s front page when I saw this question, “What do you think is the worst part of having a child?” Here are the top-voted responses.

Source: Reddit