She Let Her Niece Live With Another Family For A Week, Despite Her Apology

I read a post where an aunt talks about a problem with her 13-year-old adopted niece. To keep it simple, let’s call the aunt Rose and the niece Mary.

Rose sent Mary to live with her other uncle for a week. The problem is Mary barely knows her other uncle. 

Why was Mary living with her aunt?

woman questioning things MSN
Image Credit: DepositPhotos/HASLOO

To give you a little context, Rose’s brother was Mary’s father. He passed away four years ago. Mary’s mother also passed away twelve years ago—making Mary an orphan.

Since she had a better relationship with her father’s relatives, it was evident that her aunt Rose was the better relative to adopt her. 

Why did Rose send Mary away for a week?

Offended Woman Standing With Open Arms On Pink Background MSN Shocked Angry
Image Credit: VitalikRadko/DepositPhotos

The past few weeks have been hard for Rose. Whenever they disagreed, Mary seemed to develop an ungrateful and annoying attitude, saying that she’d rather stay with her other uncle. Although Rose knows she doesn’t really mean it, especially since Mary isn’t close with them. 

Rose has a high-paying job to provide her with more than the average family can, and she can spoil her niece with everything she wants. The main conflict happened when Rose had enough and told Mary to pack her things and stay with her other uncle for a week. 

How did Mary react to her aunt’s sudden statement?

Woman Screaming Yelling Looking Shocked and Angry MSN
Image Credit: Depositphotos

Mary was taken aback and immediately apologized. She admitted that she didn’t mean what she said. However, Rose’s decision was made. She told Mary to at least try and experience living with her other uncle and see if she wanted to stay or go back to living with her. 

A week passed, and Rose called to ask if she’d like to return home, to which Mary replied yes. 

What happened when Mary returned home?

Woman Looking Sad Angry, Turning Tumbs Down Shocked MSN
Image Credit: Depositphotos

If you guessed that Mary wasn’t talking to her aunt, you got it right.

Rose gave Mary time and space before discussing her experience with her other uncle. After a few days, they had a conversation about what happened. Mary said her uncle was nice, but his wife made her feel unwelcome. Mary was uncomfortable for the whole week and expressed how she didn’t want to live with them again. 

Rose apologized and told her that even if she wanted to live with her uncle, she’d still take her back home because she loved her. 

Was Mary acting spoiled?

Woman Shrugging Her Shoulders MSN
Image Credit: pressmaster/DepositPhotos

People had different opinions on Mary’s outburst. Some said Rose spoiled her so much that she didn’t know how to be grateful anymore.

Others agreed, saying that Mary was trying to manipulate Rose, and added that she needs to learn to handle disagreements in a healthy manner because things won’t always go her way.

Rose Was Acting Too Harsh 

two girls showing thumbs MSN
Image Credit: DepositPhotos/kanzefar

On the other hand, most of the commenters said Rose was acting too harshly on Mary and that she should’ve known that it was only a typical teenager’s response.

Rose should have acted like an adult. 

Mary is Just a Teenager, What Would You Expect

Woman White Shirt Scared MSN
Image Credit: EdZbarzhyvetsky/Depositphotos

Indeed, teenagers often speak out of anger. Mary did say that she didn’t mean it and that she didn’t actually want to live with her other uncle.

Maybe she was just trying to see if Rose would abandon her, which may have been an unconscious reaction to losing her parents.

Did Rose do the right thing by letting Mary live with her other uncle?

Woman crying of heartbreak-MSN
Image Credit: DepositPhotos/olly18

There were a lot of mixed opinions about what Rose did. Others criticized her, saying that Mary would develop abandonment issues, while some told her it was the right decision to make Mary learn her lesson. 

Should Rose Have Known Better?

Unhappy woman cringe - MSN
Image Credit: DepositPhotos/Syda_Productions

The bottom line is Rose was the adult here. She could have known better. We have to take into consideration that Mary had no other family.

Her guardian is her aunt, and the thought of her only guardian sending her away would naturally hurt her. 

Did She Break Her Trust?

Bored Teenage Girl Being Told Off By Mother MSN
Image Credit: HighwayStarz/DepositPhotos

Since she was an orphan, Rose was the only person Mary trusted. She must’ve thought it was easy for Rose to pass her off to other people, which may have broken her trust in her aunt.

Not to mention that she’s already dealing with the loss of her parents, so it would have been nice if Rose had spared her the trauma of being abandoned.  

The Top 10 Saddest Songs of All Time – Be Prepared for #1 To Hit You Hard

Woman Sad and Crying and Depressed and Emotional MSN
Image Credit: HayDmitriy on Depositphotos

I was searching the internet for great music to listen to when I came across an interesting thread titled, “What is the saddest song you’ve ever heard?” Here are some of the responses with the most upvotes.

14 All-Time Favorite Celebrities Exposed as Secret Jerks-Prepare to Be Surprised

Oprah Winfrey MSN

I recently discovered an online discussion listing beloved celebrities who were revealed to have undesirable behind-the-scenes personas. As I read about the hidden sides of these public figures, my perceptions of them were flipped completely.

Which Celebrity Couple Has a Net Worth Bigger Than Most Countries? Find Out Now

George Clooney, Amal Alamuddin MSN
Image Credit: arp on Depositphotos

Want to know which Hollywood couples are hoarding significant fortunes? We’ve highlighted and broken down individual net worth figures for fifty of the world’s most celebrated and richest celebrity couples

The Dark Side of Aging: 10 Things That Will Drive You Crazy as You Grow Older

Man Unhappy Angry Pointing at Camera MSN
Image Credit: Depositphotos

I recently saw this question online, “What are you starting to dislike more as you get older?” Here are the top-voted responses.

I Can’t Believe I Didn’t Know This Until Now: Embarrassing Things People Learned Way Too Late In Life

Serious Woman Crossing Her Arms No
Image credit: DepositPhotos

I recently scrolled the internet’s front page when I saw this question, “What’s something you learned “embarrassingly late” in life?” Here are the top-voted responses.

From Boomers to Gen Z: The Childhood Trends That Faded Away

Woman With Disgusted Expression MSN Angry Shocked

I recently saw this question online, “What was common when you were young but is rare now that you’re older?”

Let’s delve into the top-voted responses, which shed light on these nostalgic elements of the past that hold significance to many.

Did You Fall for These 10 Commonly Believed Myths? Science Sets the Record Straight

Man Looking Shocked and Surprised, Unbelievable MSN
Image Credit: Depositphotos

I recently saw this question online, “What is a popular belief that is scientifically proven wrong?” 

Are you thinking of something you know now? Here are the responses that received the most upvotes.

Source: Reddit